Categories
Beyond

Khambata questions Tata Trusts on listing and succession

Former trustee questions leadership decisions, alleged reversals on listing and governance within Tata Trusts

The growing differences within Tata Trusts have taken another turn, with senior advocate and former trustee Darius Khambata questioning the decisions surrounding Tata Sons chairman N Chandrasekaran’s proposed third term and the possible public listing of the holding company.

In a strongly worded four-page letter dated November 17, Khambata responded to allegations made by Tata Trusts vice-chairmen Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh. He rejected their claims about his role in the internal disagreements and accused them of selectively presenting facts while avoiding questions about their own decisions.

The latest exchange has brought the leadership succession debate at Tata Sons and the future of its ownership structure back into focus. At the centre of the dispute are Chandrasekaran’s reappointment, the proposed listing of Tata Sons and the role of Tata Trusts in protecting the group’s long-standing governance model.

One of Khambata’s main objections concerns what he described as a change in position by Srinivasan and Singh on the proposed listing of Tata Sons. He questioned why the two vice-chairmen had supported keeping the company privately held in March 2024, May 2025 and July 2025, but changed their stance in April 2026.

According to Khambata, the two have not adequately explained the reasons behind this shift. He also argued that such an important decision should have been discussed at a formal meeting of the trusts rather than through letters and media statements.

He maintained that the debate over listing should involve all trustees, given its implications for the ownership and governance of one of India’s largest business groups.

The proposed listing has become a major point of disagreement within the Tata Group. Tata Trusts collectively hold a little over 66% of Tata Sons, while the Shapoorji Pallonji Group owns approximately 18%. A public listing could provide the minority shareholder with an opportunity to unlock the value of its investment.

Khambata has argued that retaining Tata Trusts’ control over Tata Sons is central to the Tata model. He believes this control is not simply about retaining influence but forms part of the trustees’ responsibility to protect the trusts’ principal asset.

He also rejected the suggestion that maintaining this structure could threaten the tax-exempt status of the charitable trusts. Referring to the Supreme Court’s 2021 judgment in the Tata-Cyrus Mistry dispute, he challenged the interpretation presented by the two vice-chairmen.

The other major issue concerns the circumstances surrounding Chandrasekaran’s proposed third five-year term as executive chairman of Tata Sons.

Khambata insisted that there was no contradiction in his position on Chandrasekaran’s reappointment. He said the chairman’s overall performance had been excellent and acknowledged his significant contribution to the Tata Group over the years.

He explained that he had supported the proposal for another term after reviewing the performance figures presented by Chandrasekaran at a trustees’ meeting in July 2025. The trustees had unanimously passed a resolution on July 28, 2025, recommending his reappointment.

However, Khambata said his November 2 letter was not questioning Chandrasekaran’s performance or his suitability to lead the group. His objection was directed at how the Tata Sons board handled the decision on September 17, 2026.

The sequence of events leading to that meeting has now become a central part of the dispute.

On August 12, Chandrasekaran informed the Tata Sons board that he did not wish to seek another term when his existing tenure ended in February 2027. According to Khambata, the trustees met the following day and agreed to respect his decision and begin forming a selection committee to identify a successor.

He said the agreement was reached by all trustees, including Srinivasan and Singh.

However, the Tata Sons Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC) met on September 3 and unanimously recommended that Chandrasekaran reconsider his decision and continue as chairman. The board subsequently approved his third five-year term at its September 17 meeting, despite opposition from Tata Trusts chairman Noel Tata.

Khambata has questioned whether Srinivasan, as a Tata Trusts nominee director, brought the August 13 understanding to the attention of the NRC before it recommended Chandrasekaran’s continuation.

He argued that this was an important part of the sequence of events

Khambata also rejected allegations that he had attempted to engineer Srinivasan’s temporary removal as a trustee in October 2025 to change the composition of Tata Trusts and influence its decision-making.

He pointed out that he had voted in favour of Srinivasan’s reappointment both in October 2025 and again on November 11, 2025. He argued that these votes contradicted the suggestion that he was working to remove the vice-chairman from the trusts.

He also defended the appointment of Neville Tata as a trustee, noting that Vijay Singh had proposed Bhaskar Bhatt at the same meeting and that both appointments received unanimous support.

The disagreement also involves an October 17, 2024 resolution concerning the reappointment of trustees. Khambata accused Srinivasan and Singh of selectively invoking earlier resolutions while overlooking their own decisions, including their opposition to Mehli Mistry’s reappointment.

Khambata’s term as a trustee of the Sir Ratan Tata Trust and Sir Dorabji Tata Trust ended on November 9. He had informed Tata Trusts chairman Noel Tata and chief executive Siddharth Sharma on November 2 that he would not seek another term.

The internal differences have become more significant following the Reserve Bank of India’s latest position on Tata Sons’ regulatory status.

On November 16, the RBI reiterated that Tata Sons must comply with regulations applicable to upper-layer non-banking financial companies (NBFCs), including the mandatory listing requirement.

Tata Sons had previously sought to surrender its registration as a core investment company, but the RBI rejected its application in September 2026. This kept the question of a public listing alive and added pressure on the company to address its regulatory obligations.

The proposed listing has also raised concerns about the future relationship between Tata Sons and the charitable trusts that control it. While supporters of listing argue that it could improve transparency and provide liquidity to shareholders, opponents believe it could affect the existing governance structure.

Khambata has maintained that the Tata model depends on the trusts retaining control of Tata Sons and fulfilling their responsibility to protect the institution’s long-term interests.

Despite the sharp exchanges, he has called for the differences to be resolved through discussions rather than personal accusations. He said he had previously attempted to initiate dialogue but had not received responses from fellow trustees.

The latest letter has further exposed the disagreements over succession planning, trustee appointments and corporate governance within the Tata Group. With the RBI’s listing requirement still unresolved and Chandrasekaran’s third term approved by the board, the coming weeks could prove important for the future direction of Tata Sons.

The dispute is therefore no longer limited to individual leadership decisions. It has developed into a wider debate over who should shape the future of Tata Sons, how the Tata Trusts should exercise their authority and whether the group’s traditional governance structure can remain intact amid regulatory and shareholder pressures.