Categories
Beyond

IRDAI fines Star Health ₹2 cr over claim violations

Regulator flags unjustified claim rejections, unsupported deductions and poor communication with health insurance policyholders

The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) has imposed a penalty of ₹2 crore on Star Health and Allied Insurance Company for violations in the handling of health insurance claims, including rejecting claims on unjustified grounds and making deductions that were not supported by policy conditions.

In an order dated November 20, 2026, the insurance regulator said it had found instances where the insurer rejected health insurance claims, including those related to COVID-19 treatment, on grounds that were not sustainable under the applicable policy terms. It also flagged cases where deductions were made from claim settlements without adequate justification.

The regulator raised concerns over the manner in which the company communicated its decisions to policyholders. Customers were not consistently informed about the specific policy provisions used to reject their claims or reduce the amounts payable. This left them without sufficient information to understand the decisions or challenge them effectively.

The ₹2 crore penalty has been divided into two parts. IRDAI imposed ₹1 crore for violations relating to the repudiation of health insurance claims and another ₹1 crore for unsupported deductions and inadequate communication of claim settlement decisions.

The action follows an inspection of Star Health conducted between January 31 and February 11, 2022. The regulator subsequently issued a show-cause notice to the insurer on December 4, 2024, seeking an explanation for the violations. A personal hearing was held on June 18, 2025, before the final order was issued.

During its inspection, IRDAI examined the insurer’s handling of health insurance claims and found instances where claims, including COVID-19-related hospitalisation claims, had been rejected on grounds that did not hold under the applicable policy conditions.

The regulator also discovered that certain deductions from claim payouts were not backed by the terms and conditions of the insurance policies. In several cases, the disputed amounts were paid by the insurer only after IRDAI pointed out the discrepancies during its inspection.

The findings raised concerns about the insurer’s claim assessment practices and the transparency of its settlement process. Health insurance policies contain specific conditions governing exclusions, waiting periods, sub-limits and other deductions. However, insurers are expected to ensure that every rejection or reduction in a claim amount is supported by the relevant policy provisions.

IRDAI said the failure to communicate these provisions clearly deprived policyholders of an informed basis to question the insurer’s decisions.

The penalty has been imposed under Section 102 of the Insurance Act, 1938, along with provisions of the IRDAI (Health Insurance) Regulations, 2016, and the IRDAI (Third Party Administrators – Health Services) Regulations, 2016.

Apart from the financial penalty, IRDAI raised concerns over discounts negotiated by Star Health with its network hospitals. The regulator found that such discounts were not consistently reflected in hospital bills or communicated to policyholders.

When insurers negotiate discounts with network hospitals, customers should be able to understand how those reductions have been accounted for in their final bills and insurance settlements. The lack of clear disclosure can create confusion over the amount charged by hospitals and the amount paid by insurers.

To address these concerns, IRDAI has directed Star Health to make its claim settlement letters more detailed and transparent. The insurer must separately mention the amounts allowed, disallowed and treated as non-payable, along with applicable discounts and any reduction in the sum insured.

This will help policyholders understand how their claims have been assessed and identify the reasons for any difference between the hospital bill and the amount reimbursed or settled by the insurer.

The regulator also cautioned Star Health over collecting renewal premiums more than 90 days before the expiry of policies. Another concern involved the failure to provide complainants with details of the Insurance Ombudsman, an independent mechanism through which policyholders can seek redressal of insurance-related grievances.

IRDAI, however, took note of the corrective measures initiated by the company on these two issues.

As part of its directions, IRDAI has asked Star Health to place the order before its board of directors and provide a copy of the minutes of the board’s deliberations. The company must also submit an Action Taken Report to the regulator within 90 days, detailing the steps taken to comply with the directions.

The insurer has been directed to remit the ₹2 crore penalty within 45 days of receiving the order.

The action is significant for health insurance policyholders as it reinforces the need for fair claim settlement practices and greater accountability among insurers. While insurance companies can reject claims that fall outside policy coverage, such decisions must be supported by clearly stated policy conditions.

The order also highlights the importance of transparent communication, particularly when claims are partially settled or deductions are made. For customers, a detailed settlement statement is essential to understand what has been paid, what has been excluded and whether the insurer has applied the policy terms correctly.

The regulatory action comes amid growing scrutiny of health insurance claim settlements and consumer complaints over rejected claims, unexpected deductions and delays in reimbursements. It serves as a reminder that policyholders are entitled to clear explanations and fair treatment when making claims under their health insurance policies.